|
Toxic
Mold Case In California Settles For $22 Million
by Natalie White, Staff
Writer January, 2006
|
(This article was originally published in Lawyers
Weekly USA, another Dolan Media publication.)
A California family recently negotiated a landmark
$22.6 million settlement in a toxic mold case,
claiming that moldy lumber used to build their
house created a "poison prison" that
severely injured their son.
As one of the first successful mold lawsuits against
a lumber yard — and the largest to involve
a single-family home — the case should put
the lumber industry on notice, said the family's
attorney, Brian D. Witzer. "We hope this
settlement sends a signal to lumber yards nationwide
to treat mold growth issues seriously and establish
polices to protect the public's health and safety,"
Witzer said. Witzer predicted the settlement will
spur an onslaught of similar claims, saying that
mold litigation could become the "next asbestos,"
noting that his firm has handled several cases
in the last few years that have ended with settlements
of more than $1 million.
But attorneys for the defense believe the settlement
is an aberration caused by unfavorable rulings
prior to trial. The settlement was reached the
day after Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Victoria
G. Chaney excluded 10 of 17 expert witnesses for
the lumber company, because the company missed
court deadlines for witness lists and then backdated
documents, according to Witzer. In published reports
after the settlement was announced, the company
said in a statement that it believed jurors would
have "completely vindicated" it they
had been able to hear its witnesses, which included
a microbiologist and a toxicologist.
None of the 17 defendants, including the lumber
company, which agreed to pay $13 million, admitted
any wrongdoing. The other defendants in the suit
— which included the general contractor,
construction supervisor, framer, engineer, roofing
company, plumber and window installer —
agreed to pay a combined $9.6 million as part
of the settlement. Dream home turned nightmare
The Gormans contend their son, Kellen, suffered
serious neurological brain damage because of exposure
to toxic molds growing on framing studs that had
been improperly stored at Crenshaw Lumber Co.
in Gardena, Calif. The studs were used to build
the Gormans' $1.9 million home in Manhattan Beach.
The Gormans moved into their home in 1999.
Prior to that, Witzer said, the family had a spotless
health record. But soon after moving in, they
began to suffer respiratory and sinus problems.
At first the family thought the mold throughout
their home was caused by living close to the ocean
in an area of high humidity. They wiped it off
the walls and woodwork, but it kept returning.
Eventually they called an environmental company
to advise them how to get rid of the mold, and
the company told them to move out immediately.
They did not believe the situation was that serious,
however, and called another company. "Just
from their physical observations, that company
told them to get out right away, that staying
was a health hazard," Witzer said. Subsequent
testing showed that the house was contaminated
with dangerous molds.
The Gormans finally moved out after two years.
But by then, their son Kellen had suffered irreparable
damage, including brain lesions and cysts. At
age 5, he still functions as a 1 1/2 year old
and needs round-the-clock care. His two sisters,
now 7 and 3, did not suffer serious health problems.
Witzer said an MRI conducted when Kellen was 3
1/2 years old revealed the lesions and, when compared
to a problem-free MRI performed when he was 1,
clearly showed the jury that the youngster's brain
had been damaged.
The defense attempted to keep out medical testimony
regarding the child's neurological injuries, but
the judge ruled there was enough evidence to allow
jurors to hear the opinions of doctors linking
the damage to exposure to dangerous molds. Other
powerful evidence came in the form of environmental
testing and blood serum testing, which showed
high levels of exposure to molds.
Kellen's father also complained of cognitive and
neurological problems such as memory loss, which
the plaintiffs' medical experts testified is associated
with exposure to certain fungi, Witzer said. Head
in the sand?
Witzer said the owner of the lumber company testified
at trial that he did not believe the mold on the
lumber was dangerous and that the company did
not have a policy to prevent mold from growing
on its lumber. "He indicated that, yes, there
was black material on the wood prior to delivery,
but that in his opinion this was just black stains
or harmless molds," Witzer said. "This
is just inconsistent with all the scientific evidence
that is out there now."
He said Crenshaw did not follow industry recommendations
to cover lumber and keep it dry to prevent mold.
"Basically [Crenshaw] ignored the instructions
from the supplier to keep [the wood] dry, and
they just left it out in the rain," Witzer
said. "They didn't keep it raised twelve
inches off the ground and they didn't cover it.
In fact, they kept the lumber in a puddle, just
operating with their heads in the sand."
Although he believes mold litigation is poised
to take off, Witzer warned that attorneys will
have to put $250,000 or more into a case and be
willing to risk failure. He said mold cases are
typically very complicated, involving expensive
medical testing that is usually not covered by
health insurance, intensive environmental testing
and costly experts whose travel expenses add up
quickly, since many top mold authorities live
out of the country. "You have to treat it
like a poisoning case, meticulously building up
all the evidence and bringing in the top experts,"
Witzer said. "This is a potentially wonderful
area of litigation, but a toxic mold case cannot
be handled like an automobile accident case."
|
|
The
Air Technology Advantage |
|
Certified
Inspectors |
|
Accredited Laboratories |
|
Thorough Inspections |
|
Detailed Testing
& Reporting |
| |
Expert Consulting
& Results Interpretation |
|
Scientific Documentation |
|
Disclosure |
 |
8(a) Certified |
, busty ebony women, dad spanks daughter, housewife voyeur, gay teens in jockstraps, toys in pussy, she licked my asshole, black fetish, sylvia garcia houston, facial tattoos, bbw phone sex, downloads free sex movies, amateur facials amber, dip set bird gang, anime big tits, leather bitch, blonde babes hot, belladonna rimjob, sloppy wives, big butts in brazil, naked male actors, cock cum pierced, dual layer dvd media, free mature or mom adult thumbnail galleries, military marine dress hat, gang bang cum, happens during the female orgasm, vintage movie posters, ghetto pussy, ambers ass, hey asshole, big blow hustler, son and mom incest comis, reid park zoo tucson, hentai blowjob, hairy crotches, teen lesbian reality porn, tiffany teen videos, celeb fake nudes, hung shemale escort, ticket swap, , , lynda leigh pornstar, hardcore norma jean, pierced female, clit tight, gay anal cum, xp won't boot, double penetrations black dicks, lesbians in showers, bdsm mistress transvestite san antonio, bo peep breast, wet shaved, scat pants, mature babe, male domination sex movies, naked fat guys, bbs schoolgirls, bdsm torture pain, horny asian girls, free vaginal pic thumb nails, fart in my face, wwf girls in thongs, la, mountain dew fisting, cartoon cocks, sister upskirt, virtual reality nudity, nude young moms, standard poodle stud, college coed fucking, young ebony, erotic nikki nails, fucking pornstars, free swallow cum movies, , hot naked guys, smoking high school girls, bisexual shemales, tattoos on butt, glamour lingerie galleries, extreme hardcore mature free galleries, teeny toons, naked beach women, creampie cunts cream filled pussy, nurses fucks patient, coed breasts, sex on web cams, tips on dating, ethniissing, celebrety sex senes, nude male art, briana banks xxx, boob pop outs, forced to get naked, amateur suck, exotic bbw, hardcore hospital, girl in uniform, silvia saint videos, extreme sport game free, asian indian girls, midget gangbang, pierced clit videos, office xp professional crack, ebony all girl dildo sex, felina lingerie, paparazzi oops photos, milf movie, lesbians fucking dildos, wife swap party, sexual spanking stories, do girls have stronger leg muscles than boys, extreme outdoor bondage, silicone breast implants dallas, white dick in black pussy, topless brunette, enormous egg literature guide, asian lesbian free, mouth fisting, gay ass fisting, olsen upskirt, free latin porn babes, adult games free, teen bdsm, first sex teacher, erotic adult toys, word perfect office 12 crack, britney spears fucking porn, ethnic feet fetish, hottest chicks, beautiful topless bikini girls, , bronx zoo address, kinky bondage sex, crossdress cheerleader, big bubble butts, tor boobs, sex toys adult shops, cocksucker faggot swallow, military truck model kits, hot brazilian trans, bi gangbang, kristys mpegs beastiality, maha kumbh mela, blonde lesbian orgy, lucha erotica, sexy shaved pussy, fantasy hand jobs, japanese incest cartoon, real coed sex, his ass her mouth, stop smoking hypnosis wa, pussy stretching, amature hairy teens, free cfnm clips, sluty nurse, male gay sex, amputee leg, milf and son, redhead hairy pussy, mature gay dads, sweaty asshole, bad ass teens, russian blowjob, teeny tiny, acrobatic skill, burn by speculum weighted, free live sex feeds from amsterdam, forced gay sex, beastiality stories, las vegas party bus, gay face, forced strip video, free pics mature hardcore double penetration, drunk party girl, carolina panters cheerleaders, handjob blogs, dad son fucking, scat windrow turner, bubble butt hunks, her first black cock, free beastiality movies, american indian torture, girls masturbating in public, tiny tove filmography, cameo intimate lingerie, very big boobs, nude redhead girls, finger pussy, girls in muddy boots, shemale pantyhose galleries, manga schoolgirls, women nude, gay asian sex, teen cocks, lizzie mcguire porn, water pussy masturbation, soccer moms fucking, audio sounds of women orgasm, hot lesbian feet, fucking wife, couples who swap home movies, free facial cumshots, legs stockings nylons raised skirts, free sex web cam chat, college ffm, free anal porn, dad on boy, teen celebs naked, porn on dvd, kimberly stripper midget, celebrety addresses, hot nude brunette, chinese hardcore, facial gang bang, mother handjob, ebony lesbians fucking, private high schools vs. public high schools, dixie chicks mp3, cfnm cumshots, ethnic feet fetish, 'wife swallow black', female public flashers, small dick gallery, naked brunettes, free naked secretary bitches, hot celebrety pics, sexy skinny men, free nude cartoons, gay porn dads sons, big dick in tight pussy, women boobs, granny lesbians, , i fuck my maid, fat ass fuck, highschool chicks, fuck that bitch, sexy womens feet, studs making out, bbw vids, skinny mature brunette, free adult web sites, nylon fetish tgp, free virtual reality teen sex websites, upskirts cams, women in bedroom bondage, skinny asian nudes, nude futurama toons, exam gyno speculum video, under 18 sluts, bangbus thumb nails, naked housewife gallery, suck my own dick, superhero hentai, hot sexy redheads, tight throat, hardcore ffm porn, bikinis, boobs brunette, shave ice machines, brittany spears pregnant, asain schoolgirls, pee closeup, porn disney cartoons, pegasus fantasy mp3, free tranny movie clips, ball cock bondage, extreme close up, chubby girlfriends, canadian patriotic tattoos, sylvia youngs theater school, animal penetrations, sex ffm, fantasy fest body painting photos, sexy asian models, audio movie clips, big tits in bras, lesbian double fisting, playboy beach babes, pussy and dildos, punk sluts, nipple covers, spanking digest, naked chubby/plumdhead women, cheerleader suck, ebony group sex, healthy body fat percentage, latin pornstar, muscular gay men, girl spanking, hot latin guys, lesben sex in the shower, deepest vagina, 12 flexible ducting, ani difranco untouchable face, justin caliente boots, 25 weeks pregnant, age 8 military boys school, creampie eating stories, shemale female, sex with a horse, dildo clips, my nude mom, skinny girl cunt, extreme zoo sex, old midgets, gay stud videos, mexican cock, throat gagged, swinger group galleries, gay public, , tanned lesbian, husbands forced to watch, amateur home sex, school uniform blowjob, outdoor pool furniture, incest the family pic post, erotica male, irigaray speculum, acrobatic nymphets com, acrobatic moves, erotic youth photos, nude mature ladies, busty redhead hardcore thumbnails, jorja fox pregnant, orgasm denial stories, free lesbian domination vids, male masturbation ejaculation, adult baby girls, free lesbian galleries, squirter orgasms, , clips music, spanking gay, , wrinkled tits, license plate swap scrapbooking, hot club de paris, rimjob vids, dvd store adult, jizz covered tit, latex flexible floor patch, lactating celebreties, bbw erotica, bondage movies, retro games free, connecting dating agency, 39 weeks pregnant, secretary fucked, college coeds nude webcams, cute chubby teen, boys swallows, teen outdoor stripping, enormous natural boobs, totally shaved, yankee suck, free horny british butt sluts, oral sex clips, gushing vagina, free silicone tit movies, jordan capri blowjob, high quality sex closeup, nude fat chicks, horny teen cheerleaders, adult machine, peter north facial blasts, anal redhead, older bisexual men pics, bisexual teen, diaper bags for dads, hot teens in micro thongs, ladies dirty used panties, baby hustler sex toys, free creampie surprise movies, tiny lolita gallery, clothed women naked men, free voyeur websites, milf hardcore, tattoo cover up, big boob bikinis, extreme network inc, duke lacross rape trial, gang bang hentai, facial blowjob, little bo peep adult costume, lesbian gothiorn, midget oral sex, 65 guy creampie, gay live, flexible magnetic strip, tit fucking bitches, facial slut, teen maid, pantyhose office sex, tranny lover, hingis upskirt, big ass women, gay male underwear, , male sexual domination practices, jodie marsh naked, cheerleader blowjobs, cane women bare ass free sites rape videos, cum fart, upskirt school girl, jlo paparazzi pics, youth underage sex, snowballing and cum swap, gang anal, voyeur sex movies, where does spiderman live, asians girls, bisexual group sex, free maid porn, daytona beach condo rentals, secretary fuck movies, college fuck party, free teacher student sex videos, pornstar tits, teen blow job, cfnm fantasy, newgrounds sucks balls, femdom maids, dating articles, nude man, extreme running events, skinny ass, chubby swingers, 3d lesbian toons, criticism literary plath sylvia, erected nipples, midget lesbos, swap clothes, what makes unix flexible, video game girls hentai, beastiality brazil, gay athletes, dirty soccer moms, gay guys in showers, large milky melons, avril lavigne pussy, adult talent for hire brazil, young booty, free ebony twinks, celeb hardcore, throat fuck movie, feet teen, dirty little secret-all american rejects, teen sex videos, how to give a throat job, gay men naked, citizen f-12 swiss-type screw machine, cfnm doctor female, doc johnson adult toys, flintstones hentai, jizz junkies, ass then to mouth, lesbian gothic girls, stocking foot jobs, free gay anal, bisexual sex pics, dating advice and tips, ass her mouth, too young too fuck, how to suck a dick, young girl blowjob, long oversized nipples, topless brunette, tranny handjob, young twinks masturbating, chubby teen videos, live police audio, female smoking & masterbation, fuck girl, retro games online, zoo videos sexo, toon disney hentai, dads twinks, butt grab, housewife naked real, ebony anal sex, custom sex toys, paparazzi companys, true adult stories water masturbation, free voyeur up skirt shots, nude celeb gallery, furry sex, gothic teen girl pics, forced strip search, gay military vids, gyno nurses exam, toon dictionary xxx, lamar owens and rape, twink cock, asain anal, teen girls in bras, miss big ass brazil, good oral and written communication skills, dirty videoclips, bbb silicone, dumb bitches, , secretary anal story, interracial gangbang creampie, british milf, teenage female genitalia, aunt spanking, indian hardcore sex, kd15 silicone, indian pussy free gallery, , naked men jacking off, gothic nudes free, free teen girls clips, scat boys, webcam twinks, group sex story, gangbang audition, schoolgirls in stockings sading, pubic hair closeup, cowboy bebop porn, incest recovery inpatient centers, ethnic blowjob access, beastiality stories, celebs caught thong, web cam xxx, virgin masturbation, fuck teen, big boob enormous giant gigantic huge large massive, facts on school uniforms, fergie nude, free young twink pics, lingerie for young teens, mature in pantyhose, nylon mesh laundry bag, teen in thong, brazil playboy mag, old handjob, bbw group sex, celeb boots gallery, upskirt fetish, dad made me suck his penis, free galleries of men in jockstraps, young boys in briefs for free, fucking machines movies, male handjobs, tiny single women, nude beaches of australia, cute texas butt, fat shaved pussy, screwed paris hilton, rimjob pictures, sky lopez hardcore, first time facial, gay beach studs, tranny dating, stockings suspenders pussy, free vagina, sapphic movies, fast fuck, amateur cream pies, stroked my cock in nylon, trans sesso, paris blowjob, tanned hottie, bbw huge enormous obese, free nude peep shows, shemales jacking off, lingerie ddd breasts, wifes exhibitionism stories, blonde lesbian pussy, tanned lesbian, gynecology fetish, tight fuck, sexy naked cartoons, news clips archives, free closeup sex, swinger housewives galleries, long term effects of cigarette smoking, knitted stocking hats for adults, cute blonde teens models, stories of rape and incess, free amateur porn, audible french erotica, latin gays, free giant clit pic, free movie gallery clit, anime oral sex, sexy latina feet, big ass fat girls, clit long pic, sylvia gutierrez, hustler xxx magazine, speculum exam photo, biggest tits ever, reality sex videos trailors, vagina institute, free ghetto ebony fucking links, mandy tanned and big tits, oops paparazzi photo, girl sucks dick, amatuer threesome ffm, female fingering techniques, glow mouth products, cub scout outdoor activity award, very young teens in bikini's, sissy maid uniform, ebony slut galleries, female smoking fetish, free adult films, xxx lesbian strapon female domination, , celebrity legs forums, non pierced nose ring, cum on her face elaine, young bikini girls, pamella trans anderson, dvd maker software, i have a scat fetish, runway nipple slips, lesbian sex movies, tips for performing oral sex, free sexy office sluts, chinese peep girl, high hustler street, used youth archery bows, hot leg galleries, mature rimjob, retro home bar, melissa joan hart nude, shower clit, young ripe melons gianna, private duty nurse dallas, women have hairy breasts, tifany melons, free fantasy football rankings, youth worker jobs available, retro car of the future, thick latin asses, tomb raider xxx, paris hilton sex vid, , what does bdsm mean, girls locker room voyeur,
|
GSA Schedule |
|
NJ State Contract |
|
We
were more than satisfied! Our inspection
saved us over $3,800 in hidden repairs.
Ron N. - Middletown, DE
Your
inspector was thorough and very helpful
in explaining exactly what was being
done...We have already recommended
your company to friends and family.
Mary W. - Cherry Hill, NJ
We were
purchasing our first home and were
not familiar with the potential problems
associated with mold. Thanks to your
company we were able to find a mold-free
home.
Chris & Jill W. - Lansdale, PA
|
|
|
|
